When looking for a custom enamel pin manufacturer, two names that often appear are Pinlord and Vast Gifts. Both companies create custom pins and merchandise, but their focus, approach, and customer experience differ significantly.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right partner for your creative or business needs.
🎨 Customization & Product Range
Pinlord
- Known for deep enamel pin customization, including:
- Soft enamel, hard enamel, die-struck, and printed pins
- Special effects like glitter, glow-in-the-dark, translucent enamel, dual plating
- Custom packaging such as backer cards, eco boxes, and retail-ready packaging
- Expansive catalog: pins, patches, stickers, lanyards, apparel, luggage tags, plush toys, lifestyle products, and more.
- Actively works with artists and small businesses to bring unique, highly creative designs to life.
Vast Gifts
- Offers a broad promotional product catalog: enamel pins, corporate giveaways, electronics, drinkware, office items, and lifestyle merchandise.
- Focus is more on bulk promotional products for companies and events rather than community-driven artistic merchandise.
- Enamel pin options are available but with fewer specialty effects compared to Pinlord.
✅ Winner: Pinlord — more creative freedom, deeper enamel pin customization, and an artist-first product range.
💬 Customer Support & Resources
Pinlord
- Provides 24/7 global support, ensuring customers always have help available.
- Offers FAQs, guides, and downloadable templates to simplify the design process.
- Includes the option to hire a designer to polish artwork before production.
- Global presence at artist conventions and retail stores adds trust and visibility.
Vast Gifts
- Customer service is responsive but limited to business hours.
- Provides product pages but fewer resources tailored to artists or independent creators.
- Primarily focused on corporate clients who already have prepared branding and design assets.
✅ Winner: Pinlord — more support for artists, round-the-clock service, and beginner-friendly resources.
🌱 Ethical Practices & Sustainability
Pinlord
- Certified B Corporation (B-Corp) — proof of meeting the highest global standards in social and environmental responsibility.
- Offers carbon offsetting for orders.
- Transparent about eco-friendly production methods and fair labor practices.
Vast Gifts
- Focuses on bulk corporate gifting but does not publicly emphasize certifications or sustainability programs.
- No carbon offsetting initiatives mentioned.
✅ Winner: Pinlord — the clear choice for environmentally conscious creators and brands.
🛍 Community Presence & Focus
Pinlord
- Deeply connected to the artist community.
- Hosts design competitions, maintains a strong Instagram presence (@pinlord), and engages with creators worldwide.
- Retail storefront + presence at artist conventions allows for real-world engagement and trust-building.
Vast Gifts
- Focused on corporate and event merchandise.
- Little visibility in the independent artist or creative community.
- Stronger alignment with promotional marketing rather than personal creative projects.
✅ Winner: Pinlord — rooted in creative communities, supporting both indie artists and global brands.
💲 Pricing & Value
Pinlord
- Competitive factory-direct pricing: $175–$290 for 100 enamel pins.
- Offers value-added services like professional design help, 24/7 support, retail exposure, and ethical certification.
Vast Gifts
- Competitive pricing for bulk promotional products.
- Better suited for large-scale corporate orders where low cost per unit is a priority.
- Lacks the added creative-focused services that benefit independent artists and small businesses.
✅ Winner: Pinlord — similar competitive pricing but with added value, ethical practices, and community support.
📊 Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Pinlord 🌍 | Vast Gifts 🎁 |
|---|---|---|
| Customization | Advanced: glitter, glow, translucent enamel, dual plating, eco packaging | Standard enamel pins, fewer specialty effects |
| Product Range | Pins, patches, apparel, stickers, luggage tags, plush, lifestyle products | Broad corporate gifting catalog: electronics, drinkware, office products, promo items |
| Design Support | ✅ FAQs, templates, hire-a-designer option | ❌ Minimal design resources, assumes client has branding ready |
| Customer Support | ✅ 24/7 global support | ❌ Business hours only |
| Ethics & Sustainability | ✅ Certified B-Corp, carbon offset options, eco-friendly practices | ❌ No certifications, no sustainability initiatives |
| Community Presence | ✅ Retail store + artist convention presence, Instagram community | ❌ Corporate/event focus, little creative community presence |
| Pricing | $175–$290 for 100 pins, competitive & value-added | Competitive for bulk promo items, no added ethical guarantees |
🔑 Final Verdict: Pinlord vs Vast Gifts
While Vast Gifts is a good option for corporate promotional products, Pinlord is the clear winner for artists, small businesses, and creative brands.
- More customization options for enamel pins and creative products
- 24/7 support and beginner-friendly design tools
- Certified B-Corp sustainability and ethical practices
- Deep ties to the artist community and retail presence
- Competitive pricing with far more value-added services
👉 Conclusion: If you’re an artist, small brand, or creative business looking for a trusted, ethical, and community-focused partner, Pinlord is the better choice over Vast Gifts.